​Legal Blog

Carol Shaw
Director, Head of Employment Law
01295 204140
cshaw@se-law.co.uk

Uber petitions a ‘leapfrog’ appeal to the Supreme Court

by Carol Shaw | Nov 30, 2017 |
Man driving a car

Uber petitions a ‘leapfrog’ appeal to the Supreme Court over the EAT’s decision to uphold an Employment Tribunal’s decision that Uber drivers are ‘workers’.

What is a worker?

The term ‘worker’ is broad in the sense that it encompasses those who are ‘employees’ and individuals who work under a contract  to do or perform work or services for another party but not as client or customer for that party.

Workers’ rights

‘Employees’ are afforded a raft of employment rights that other ‘workers’ are not entitled to, for instance the right to a statutory redundancy payment or the right not to be unfairly dismissed.

However, the law recognises that there are fundamental rights that all ‘workers’ should be entitled to despite not having the status of ‘employee’, for instance the right to the national minimum wage and holiday pay.

Why did the Uber drivers issue proceedings?

The drivers issued proceedings against Uber claiming that they were not self-employed but were in fact ‘workers’ and as a result were entitled to workers’ rights.

Uber’s position was that drivers were not workers but were in fact self-employed and working in business on their own. Uber argued that it was nothing more than a “supplier of transportation services” which allowed drivers to pick-up passengers; Uber tried to rely on carefully worded contracts that referred to the drivers as self-employed.

What did the EAT conclude

The EAT upheld the Employment Tribunal’s judgment that the drivers were ‘workers’.

Why did the EAT consider the drivers to be workers.

In coming to its decision, the EAT took into consideration various factors in upholding that the drivers were workers, for instance, the fact that the drivers were required to accept at least 80% of trips offered to retain their account status and that there was no question of drivers being able to substitute their work to anyone else.

What appears to have been a particular sticking point for Uber is that the EAT agreed with the ET that the carefully drafted documentation upon which Uber relied to show the drivers were self-employed did not correspond with the practical reality of the situation.

The EAT rejected any suggestion that Uber was working for the drivers in being a “supplier of transportation services” and said that the only sensible interpretation was that the relationship was in fact the other way around ie the drivers were working for Uber.

The EAT noted that in a normal commercial environment the starting point will be the written contractual documentation, however, in this case, it noted that the ET had considered the contractual documentation should not be the end point and that it was required to consider the statutory provisions enacted to protect those who are often disadvantaged in any contractual bargain.

On the one hand, it is re-assuring to workers that this decision provides a clear warning to anyone who tries to mask behind carefully worded contracts which seek to undermine workers’ rights: the Tribunals will see past this and look at the true reality of the situation.

On the other, with the ever increasing ‘gig economy’ (of which it is estimated there are 5 million people working in this capacity in the UK) and the abolition of Tribunal fees in July 2017, will we see ‘gig economy workers’ trying to manipulate the system in the hope  of enforcing workers’ rights such as holiday pay? A recent ECJ case says that where a worker has not been allowed paid holiday, claims can be backdated to the commencement of the 1998 Working Time Regulations.

*Disclaimer: While everything has been done to ensure the accuracy of the contents of this article, it is a general guide only. It is not comprehensive and does not constitute legal advice. Specific legal advice should be sought in relation to the particular facts of a given situation.

5 comments

Leave a comment
  1. Alina Ahuza | Jul 19, 2018
    Truly great post. I just discovered your blog and needed to state that I have truly appreciated perusing your blog entries. Anyway, I'll be buying into your feed and I trust you post again soon. Delhi Escorts   Escorts in Delhi   Delhi Call Girls   Delhi Escort   Delhi Escorts Agency   Delhi Escorts Service   Call Girls in Delhi   Escort Delhi   Delhi Call Girls Service   Delhi Call Girls Photos   Delhi Escorts Girls Pics   Sexy Call Girls Pics   Sexy Girls Photos   Sexy Call Girls Numbers   Escort Service in Delhi   Russian Call Girls Service in Delhi Delhi Sexy Housewife Escorts   Delhi Hot Call Girls   Delhi Housewife Escorts Service   Hot Model in Delhi   Escort Service in Delhi   Indian Escorts in Delhi   Call Girls Number   Delhi Escort Services   Escort Services in Delhi   Delhi College Call Girls   Delhi Russian Escorts Agency   Cheap Housewife Escort Delhi   Sexy Bhabhi Numbers   Nude Call girls pics   Delhi Call Girls Pics   Call Girls Service in Delhi   Indian Sexy Housewife   Call Girl in Delhi   Call Girls in Delhi NCR   Delhi NCR Escort Service   Delhi Hot Housewife   Delhi Sexy Bhabhi Numbers   VIP Escorts Services in Delhi   Best Escorts in Delhi   Sexy Housewife in Delhi   Escort Services Delhi   Sexy bhabhi in Delhi   Housewife Escorts in Delhi   Independent Escorts in Delhi   Independent Escort Girls in Delhi   New Delhi Escort Services   Escort Service in Five Start Hotel   Five Star Escort Service   Delhi Sexy Bhabhi   Escort Service in South Delhi   Delhi Sexy Models   Call Girls Number   Delhi Luxury Escorts   VIP Escorts in Delhi   Delhi VIP Escorts   Russian Escort Agency in Delhi   Sexy Housewife in Delhi NCR   Housewife Escorts in Delhi   Cheap Model Escorts in Delhi   Hot Model Escort in Delhi   Delhi Model Escort   Delhi High Class Escorts   Delhi Model Escort Service   Delhi High Class Escorts   Call Girls   
  2. luarbiasa | Jul 16, 2018
    Anyone who thinks sitting in church can make you a Christian must also think that sitting in a garage can make you a car. cara menyembuhkan polip usus
  3. Williams | Jun 23, 2018
    These kind of car services are best for public to book your drivers online to go to your destiny. All the peoples can take the review of cheap essay writing services to download the latest version of Uber application and learns how to use their new features. The rates are also very cheap than other public transport service.
  4. jimmy | Jun 19, 2018
    nice and chacha or <a href="https://www.google.com/">chacha</a>
  5. John Moran | Dec 03, 2017
    It will be an interesting appeal to watch, thanks for the article - I've posted it to our Trello blog at zusaservices.com.   What is your take on how this will impact Uber / other gig companies in other jurisdictions?

    Leave a comment

    Legal Blog Filter

    select

    select

    Contact us

    Social Media twitter red Follow us @se_law