​Legal Blog

Carol Shaw
Director, Head of Employment Law
01295 204140
cshaw@se-law.co.uk

Uber petitions a ‘leapfrog’ appeal to the Supreme Court

by Carol Shaw | Nov 30, 2017 |
Man driving a car

Uber petitions a ‘leapfrog’ appeal to the Supreme Court over the EAT’s decision to uphold an Employment Tribunal’s decision that Uber drivers are ‘workers’.

What is a worker?

The term ‘worker’ is broad in the sense that it encompasses those who are ‘employees’ and individuals who work under a contract  to do or perform work or services for another party but not as client or customer for that party.

Workers’ rights

‘Employees’ are afforded a raft of employment rights that other ‘workers’ are not entitled to, for instance the right to a statutory redundancy payment or the right not to be unfairly dismissed.

However, the law recognises that there are fundamental rights that all ‘workers’ should be entitled to despite not having the status of ‘employee’, for instance the right to the national minimum wage and holiday pay.

Why did the Uber drivers issue proceedings?

The drivers issued proceedings against Uber claiming that they were not self-employed but were in fact ‘workers’ and as a result were entitled to workers’ rights.

Uber’s position was that drivers were not workers but were in fact self-employed and working in business on their own. Uber argued that it was nothing more than a “supplier of transportation services” which allowed drivers to pick-up passengers; Uber tried to rely on carefully worded contracts that referred to the drivers as self-employed.

What did the EAT conclude

The EAT upheld the Employment Tribunal’s judgment that the drivers were ‘workers’.

Why did the EAT consider the drivers to be workers.

In coming to its decision, the EAT took into consideration various factors in upholding that the drivers were workers, for instance, the fact that the drivers were required to accept at least 80% of trips offered to retain their account status and that there was no question of drivers being able to substitute their work to anyone else.

What appears to have been a particular sticking point for Uber is that the EAT agreed with the ET that the carefully drafted documentation upon which Uber relied to show the drivers were self-employed did not correspond with the practical reality of the situation.

The EAT rejected any suggestion that Uber was working for the drivers in being a “supplier of transportation services” and said that the only sensible interpretation was that the relationship was in fact the other way around ie the drivers were working for Uber.

The EAT noted that in a normal commercial environment the starting point will be the written contractual documentation, however, in this case, it noted that the ET had considered the contractual documentation should not be the end point and that it was required to consider the statutory provisions enacted to protect those who are often disadvantaged in any contractual bargain.

On the one hand, it is re-assuring to workers that this decision provides a clear warning to anyone who tries to mask behind carefully worded contracts which seek to undermine workers’ rights: the Tribunals will see past this and look at the true reality of the situation.

On the other, with the ever increasing ‘gig economy’ (of which it is estimated there are 5 million people working in this capacity in the UK) and the abolition of Tribunal fees in July 2017, will we see ‘gig economy workers’ trying to manipulate the system in the hope  of enforcing workers’ rights such as holiday pay? A recent ECJ case says that where a worker has not been allowed paid holiday, claims can be backdated to the commencement of the 1998 Working Time Regulations.

*Disclaimer: While everything has been done to ensure the accuracy of the contents of this article, it is a general guide only. It is not comprehensive and does not constitute legal advice. Specific legal advice should be sought in relation to the particular facts of a given situation.

793 comments

Leave a comment
  1. Daily Health Benefits | Jan 20, 2019
    I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.Daily Health Benefits
  2. burhan1 | Jan 20, 2019
    Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work! 
    안전놀이터
  3. linkseo | Jan 20, 2019
    Of course, planning a wedding from afar has its own set of challenges, however, with “Your Wedding Concierge” by your side the experience you are about to live will give you nothing but smiles to share! Have you thought about all the requirements you as well as friends and family may have before your special day, or even after? That is anything from the slightest detail of arranging transportation between the airport and your hotel, to a restaurant reservation, hotel accommodation, or even spa treatments. How about a holiday on the island after you say “I Do”? Cyprus Weddings
  4. akram khatri | Jan 20, 2019
    I just thought it may be an idea to post incase anyone else was having problems researching but I am a little unsure if I am allowed to put names and addresses on here. Zonnepanelen
  5. linkseo | Jan 20, 2019
    Hearing Aids Cyprus (Nicosia) is performed by Dr Chryssoula Thodi in the Cyprus Audiology Center cyprusaudiology.com . The Center’s main activities include detection, diagnosis, and rehabilitation of hearing and balance disorders. Within the last years, Industrial Audiology and Hearing Conservation have been added to our portfolio, upon award of a United Nations Development Project. Our equipment, software, and personnel skills are being constantly updated. Hearing Aids Cyprus
  6. ahmed | Jan 19, 2019
    gracious my god How You compose such a pleasant substance. I likewise taken a stab at something new please read and appreciateZwembaden
  7. mmssw | Jan 19, 2019
    I have a similar interest this is my page    read everything carefully and let me know what you think. Zonnepanelen installateur
  8. mmssw | Jan 19, 2019
    Profit primarily prime quality items -- you can understand them all within: Zonnepanelen kopen
  9. ahmed | Jan 19, 2019
    gracious my god How You compose such a pleasant substance. I likewise taken a stab at something new please read and appreciateZwembaden
  10. linkseo | Jan 19, 2019
    Car Specialist Cyprus Nicosia | Car Mechanic Cyprus Nicosia Car Mechanic Cyprus Nicosia
  11. burri 60 | Jan 19, 2019
    I read a article under the same title some time ago, but this articles quality is much, much better. How you do this.. affordable seo consultants
  12. linkseo | Jan 19, 2019
    τερμιτες φαρμακο κυπρος | απεντομωση τερμιτων |  Τέλος στα ενοχλητικά έντομα | Κατσαριδες, Μυρμήγκια, Τερμίτες τέλος | Πάντα σε ασφαλή πλαίσια, πάντα με αποτέλεσμα! Από την pestcontrolcy.com/  τερμιτες φαρμακο κυπρος
  13. as | Jan 19, 2019
    All the contents you mentioned in post is too good and can be very useful. I will keep it in mind, thanks for sharing the information keep updating, looking forward for more posts.ThanksHemstädning Sollentuna
  14. mmssw | Jan 19, 2019
    I just thought it may be an idea to post incase anyone else was having problems researching but I am a little unsure if I am allowed to put names and addresses on here. Zonnepanelen
  15. linkseo | Jan 19, 2019
    Extremely pleasant and fascinating post. I was searching for this sort of data and appreciated perusing this one. Continue posting. Much obliged for sharing.  lokasi kuliner
  16. linkseo | Jan 19, 2019
    I was looking of your posts on this site and I consider this site is genuinely instructive! Keep setting up..  https://www.smore.com/3wgtf-noocube-reviews-in-detail
  17. ahmed | Jan 18, 2019
    Phenomenal Blog! I might want to thank for the endeavors you have made recorded as a hard copy this post. I am trusting a similar best work from you later on too. I needed to thank you for this sites! A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing. Incredible sites!.Monoblok zwembaden
  18. ahmed | Jan 18, 2019
    Phenomenal Blog! I might want to thank for the endeavors you have made recorded as a hard copy this post. I am trusting a similar best work from you later on too. I needed to thank you for this sites! A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing. Incredible sites!.Monoblok zwembaden
  19. burri 60 | Jan 18, 2019
    I am interested in such topics so I will address       page where it is cool described. ukrayna üniversiteleri
  20. linkseo | Jan 18, 2019
    Extremely pleasant and fascinating post. I was searching for this sort of data and appreciated perusing this one. Continue posting. Much obliged for sharing.  singapore lanyard
  21. linkseo | Jan 18, 2019
    I was looking of your posts on this site and I consider this site is genuinely instructive! Keep setting up..  Academic Writers Bureau
  22. sameerapatel | Jan 18, 2019

    Vsant kunj escorts agency welcomes to you.Come with us for enjoyment with young and expert call girls in vasant kunj.if you want book call girls visit here:-

    vasant kunj escorts  ##  mahipalpur escorts  ##  connaught place escorts  ##  saket escorts  ##  vasant kunj escorts  ##  aerocity escorts  ##  dwarka escorts  ##  rohini escorts  ##  laxmi nagar escorts  ##  nehru place escorts  ##  lajpat nagar call girls  ##  karol bagh escorts  ##  greater kailash escorts  ##  ghaziabad escorts  ##  kaushambi escorts  ##  vasundhra escorts  ##  vaishali escorts  ##  indirapuram escorts  ##  noida escorts  ##  udaipur escorts  ##  hyderabad escorts  ##  cr park escorts  ##  paharganj escorts  ##  defence colony escorts  ##  south ex escorts  ##  mukherjee nagar escorts  ##  safdarjung enclave escorts  ##  chatarpur escorts  ##  chanakyapuri escorts  ##  mehrauli escorts  ##  jangpura escorts  ##  mayur vihar escorts  ##  lodhi road escorts  ##  khan market escorts  ##  nizamuddin escorts  ##  greenpark escorts  ##  ashram escorts  ##  sarita vihar escorts  ##  new friends colony escorts  ##  okhla escorts  ##  katwaria sarai escorts  ##  kalkaji escorts  ##  

  23. Merck SEO | Jan 18, 2019
    I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.  giochi di macchine
  24. Merck SEO | Jan 18, 2019
    You should for the most part prevalent together with well-performing material, which implies that see it:  gioco solitario
  25. webhostingonedollar | Jan 18, 2019
    Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. This is truly a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles. Keep up the good work!  99 rs domain godaddy
  26. bigpond.com mail | Jan 18, 2019
    This Blog is so amazing always leave people with a craving heart to go in to the depth of the words its using.bigpond.com mail
  27. mini porco | Jan 18, 2019
    This is a great article thanks for sharing this informative information. I will visit your blog regularly for some latest post. I will visit your blog regularly for Some latest post. mini porco
  28. ahmed | Jan 17, 2019
    really enlightening article post.Really anticipating examination more. Quite welcome you sharing this blog post.Thanks Againastic.Awesome blog article.Much thanks once more. ThankfulZwembad aanleg
  29. ahmed | Jan 17, 2019
    really enlightening article post.Really anticipating examination more. Quite welcome you sharing this blog post.Thanks Againastic.Awesome blog article.Much thanks once more. ThankfulZwembad aanleg
  30. burri 60 | Jan 17, 2019
    The best article I came across a number of years, write something about it on this page.  Turf
  31. bilal khan | Jan 17, 2019
    Confusing information, immense and outlandish structure, as offer especially finished with sharp examinations and thoughts, heaps of striking information and inspiration, the two of which I require, because of offer such an incredible information herehttps://fairviewgolf.net/2018/12/13/golf-clash-hack-how-to-hack-golf-clash-cheats-2017-free-gems-and-coins-december-13-2018-update-by-i
  32. Coupons Techie | Jan 17, 2019

    A beautifully written article,  if only all bloggers look at your content and learn from it than the internet would be a far better place.  

    Active target promo codesohana couponbing promotional offer code chi hair coupons Singer coupons codeanker promo codetarget promo code that always work

                 
  33. How I Work | Jan 17, 2019
    Super site! I am Loving it!! Will return once more, Im taking your food additionally, Thanks.How I Work
  34. mmssw | Jan 17, 2019
    Thanks for writing such a good article, I stumbled onto your blog and read a few post. I like your style of writing... cheap essay
  35. heena | Jan 17, 2019
    Out there, they're picking up each other. In his heart, he silently welcomed the rain. Who are we now?   Delhi escorts   Delhi Escorts   Escorts in Delhi   Escorts in Delhi  Delhi escorts   Delhi escorts   Delhi Escorts   Delhi Escorts   Escorts in Delhi   Escorts in Delhi   Delhi escorts
  36. ahmed | Jan 16, 2019
    Great site! I genuinely love the delightful way it is simple on my eyes it is. I am thinking about how I may be advised at whatever point another post has been made. I have bought in to your RSS which may work? Have an extraordinary dayPolypropyleen zwembaden
  37. ahmed | Jan 16, 2019
    Great site! I genuinely love the delightful way it is simple on my eyes it is. I am thinking about how I may be advised at whatever point another post has been made. I have bought in to your RSS which may work? Have an extraordinary dayPolypropyleen zwembaden
  38. burri 60 | Jan 16, 2019
    I read a article under the same title some time ago, but this articles quality is much, much better. How you do this.. shade ports
  39. linkseo | Jan 16, 2019
    Get free woodworking plans that will help beginners to expert craft new projects with easily . You'll find free woodworking plans for workbenches, coffee tables, picnic tables, wine racks, chicken coops, decks, pergolas, gazebos, birdhouses. www.freewoodworkingplanspdf.com
  40. linkseo | Jan 16, 2019
    I'm eager to reveal this page. I have to thank you for ones time for this especially fabulous read !! I unquestionably extremely loved all aspects of it and I likewise have you spared to fav to take a gander at new data in your site.  sarkari result 
  41. burri 60 | Jan 16, 2019
    I was surfing the Internet for information and came across your blog. I am impressed by the information you have on this blog. It shows how well you understand this subject.pomeranian boo satılık
  42. akram khatri | Jan 16, 2019
    it's really nice and meanful. it's really cool blog. Linking is very useful thing.you have really helped lots of people who visit blog and provide them usefull information. kommersiella tvister
  43. Susanne J. Levine | Jan 16, 2019
    Thanks for this article very helpful. thanks.Voice training singapore
  44. Sara Jacob | Jan 15, 2019
    Canon Printer Support Phone Number
    Canon Printer Technical Support Phone Number
    Canon Printer Technical Support Number
    Canon Printer Tech Support Phone Number
    Canon Printer Support Number
    Canon Printer Customer Support Number
    Canon Printer Helpline
    Canon Printer Helpline Number
    Canon Printer Customer Helpline Number
    Canon Printer Customer Helpline
    Printer Technical Support Number  Printer Technical Support Number is a leading technical support provider for printers.HP Printer Support phone NumberHP Printer Support Phone Number
    HP Printer Support Number
    HP Printer Support
    HP Printer Customer Support Number
    HP Printer Technical Support Number
    HP Printer Tech Support Phone Number
    Epson printer Support Phone NumberEpson Printer Support Phone Number
    Epson Printer Support Number
    Epson Printer Support
    Epson Printer Customer Support Phone Number
    Epson Printer Customer Support Number
    Epson Printer Tech Support Phone Number
    Epson Printer Tech Support Number
    Epson Printer Technical Support Number
    Printer Technical Support Number
      Canon Printer Support Phone Number
    Canon Printer Support
    Canon Printer Support Number
    Epson Printer Support Phone Number
    Epson Printer Support
    Epson Printer Support Number
    Epson Printer Support Phone Number
    Epson Printer Support
    Epson Printer Support Number
    Canon Printer Support Phone Number
    HP Printer Support Phone Number
    HP Support
    HP Printer Support
    HP Printer Support Number
    HP Printer Support Phone Number
    Epson Support
    Epson Printer Support
    Epson Printer Support Number
    Epson Printer Support Phone Number
    Canon Support
    Canon Printer Support
    Canon Printer Support Number
  45. bilal khan | Jan 15, 2019
    Good composed article. It will be steady to any individual who uses it, including me. Continue doing what you are doing – can'r hold on to peruse more postLa Telepatia Espiritual
  46. bilal khan | Jan 15, 2019
    Good composed article. It will be steady to any individual who uses it, including me. Continue doing what you are doing – can'r hold on to peruse more postLa Telepatia Espiritual
  47. Merck SEO | Jan 15, 2019
    This is useful, in any case it can be significant with the goal that you can look at the accompanying site:  vacation
  48. akram khatri | Jan 15, 2019
    On my website you'll see similar texts, write what you think.  Lịch thi đấu bóng đá
  49. burri 60 | Jan 15, 2019
    Thank you for the update, very nice site.. SEO BACKLINKS
  50. burri 60 | Jan 15, 2019
    Positive site, where did u come up with the information on this posting?I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style. Thanks a million and please keep up the effective work. visit here

    Leave a comment

    Legal Blog Filter

    select

    select

    Contact us

    Social Media twitter red Follow us @se_law